Stand mixers for baking, and more

 A good stand mixer is just as important as your oven when baking. (Consumer Reports)
A good stand mixer is just as important as your oven when baking. (Consumer Reports) (KOTA)
Published: Feb. 24, 2020 at 10:13 AM MST
Email This Link
Share on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

When it comes to baking and cooking, we put a lot of emphasis on our ovens. But could your cooking and baking be only as good as your stand mixer?

To find out, Consumer Reports’ testers made batches of chocolate chip cookies and gallons of whipped cream, and kneaded bread dough.

Testers checked for things like how much the mixers labored and vibrated, whether the bowl needed to be scraped with a spatula, and how well flours blended at low and moderate speeds.

For whipping, they timed how long it took to make whipped cream.

To assess how well the kneading attachment worked, testers dropped small amounts of blue and yellow food coloring into the dough. Ideally, the mixer would knead the dough into a uniform green color without any streaks.

But there’s more than just mixing and kneading. Many stand mixers offer attachments for doing things like making sausage or pasta, so testers checked out a few of those, too.

Testers found there’s a learning curve with some of them. It might take a few tries before you master them.

While many of the stand mixers handled some of CR’s tough tests, only two earned a CR recommendation. Both are from KitchenAid. CR recommends the 4.5-quart KitchenAid Classic. It has 10 speeds and is big enough to make about 6 dozen cookies in a single batch.

CR’s testers also tried out KitchenAid’s vegetable spiralizer attachment and found it worked well. But you end up with leftover veggie waste that doesn’t get spiralized. Testers noted that the sausage-making attachment was fairly easy to use. The pasta maker add-on took some practice, so expect some trial and error before your first successful batch.